What the study measured
In early 2023 the NSW Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water asked Tamworth to host a pilot study of how much water evaporative coolers use. Tamworth was picked because its automatic water meters could measure use hourly and, the council's report says, because the region has a high proportion of homes with these coolers. The department funded it and the University of Technology Sydney's Institute for Sustainable Futures ran it. Its report, Understanding residential evaporative cooling water use and savings, is dated October 2026 and is annexed to the council's item.
About 100 households had a second smart meter fitted to the cooler itself. Water use was measured through the 2023-24 summer, licensed contractors serviced the coolers in the winter of 2024, adjusting bleed rates and cleaning the pads, and use was measured again through the 2024-25 summer. Meters on 84 coolers returned data; after removing units with too little use and households without a confirmed service date, 48 households were analysed.
Servicing worked, a little. A running cooler's average flow fell from 25 to 22 litres an hour, and its use on a day it ran fell from 251 to 213 litres. But the serviced coolers ran on more days, an average of 81 rather than 65 a summer. Net of that, a service saved 2,000 to 4,000 litres a year, 1 to 2 per cent of a home's demand. The council's report sets out what that is worthA.
Exhibit A · from the source
The study's own report prices the same saving at $6 to $12 a year, because it assumed
a typical tariff of $3.00 a kilolitre. Tamworth charges homes $2.01 a kilolitre in
2026-27 for the first 400 kilolitres a year, and the study's average home used about 870 litres a
day, well inside that tier. At Tamworth's price the council's $4 to $8 is the right figure
(our arithmetic). Either way, the report concludes, the saving
is insufficient to offset the average optimisation material cost of $63 and the optimisation cost of $200 per household
.
What the rebate has cost
The rebate is part of the council's Water Demand Management Plan. Its rebates page offers
50 per cent of the cost of servicing an evaporative cooler, up to $200, for pads, the sump,
the pump, the float valve, the bleed hose and start-up and shut-down servicing, and says
a rebate will be provided once per year for each evaporative cooler at a specific property
.
Since the scheme started in 2019, the report says, the council has approved 2,972 of themB.
Exhibit B · from the source
That is an average of about $88 a rebate. If a rebated service saves what the study's serviced coolers saved, 2 to 4 kilolitres in a year, the council paid roughly $22 to $44 for each kilolitre saved, about 11 to 22 times the $2.01 it charges for that water. The study did not measure the rebated services themselves, so that is an estimate on its average, not a measurement (our arithmetic). The council also offers 50 per cent, up to $50 each, for ceiling fans in rooms with an evaporative cooling duct.
The report's recommendation is that councillors receive the study and
request that a future report be prepared regarding the ongoing application of water rebates for the servicing of evaporative air conditioners
.
Staff would review whether the scheme continues to provide sufficient value as a water demand management measure
.
The council's meeting update after the 10 November meeting did not mention the item, and the
minutes, which will record what councillors resolved, were not on the council's site on 11
November.
Updated 16 November 2026. The minutes of the 10 November meeting
record that councillors adopted the recommendation, 9 votes to none (minute 324/26): they received the study and asked
for a future report on the ongoing application of water rebates for the servicing of evaporative air conditioners
.
The resolution does not change the rebate. We will report the review when it reaches a council meeting. This paragraph and
one source are new.
Where the water savings actually are
Three things in the study moved far more water than a routine service.
| Lever | What the study found |
|---|---|
| A routine service | 2,000 to 4,000 litres a year per home, 1 to 2 per cent of household demand |
| Fixing a faulty cooler | 400 to 848 litres a day on the three units found running continuously; $82 to $180 a year off the bill for households that repaired leaks |
| Switching off from 8pm to 8am | 24 per cent less cooler water; coolers were left on overnight 19 per cent of the time |
The faulty units were the ones running around the clock at more than 60 litres an hour, a
pattern the study's hourly meter data showed plainly. The council's report notes it already has
targeted high water use notifications through its automated water meter system
and its customer water portal. The study recommends a targeted program for high-use homes and a
behaviour campaign on overnight switch-off, and says plainly:
a community-wide rebate to service EACs is not a cost-effective way to reduce demand
It also found a benefit it did not price. Households that had barely used their coolers used
them more once serviced. For some of them, the report says, servicing triggered a rebound effect,
enabling access to cooling during extreme heat events
,
a health benefit for older people and young children. The study estimates that about 8,000 of
Tamworth's 28,000 households have an evaporative cooler, and that coolers account for about 3.7
per cent of the city's water use. Tamworth's draft water security plan, on exhibition until 25
November, is about the far larger
question of supply.
Our view
As a water saving measure, the rebate does not survive the study Tamworth helped run. On the study's average, a service saves 2 to 4 kilolitres a year, and the council's rebate, about $88 on average, buys that water at about 11 to 22 times what it charges for it. The study's own numbers point somewhere better: the few coolers that leak around the clock, which Tamworth's meters can already flag, and the overnight running that a reminder costs almost nothing to address. The heat benefit is real, and there is a fair case for helping households keep coolers working in a heatwave. But if that is what the money is for, the review should say so and pay it on those terms, rather than counting it as water saved. Staff were right to recommend the review, and the report it produces should show what the rebate would cost per kilolitre in whatever form it proposes.
If you have a cooler, the study's cheapest advice is the overnight one: switching it off from 8pm to 8am would cut its water use by about a quarter, and an unexplained overnight reading on the water portal may be a leak. We will report the councillors' decision when the minutes are published, and the review when it reaches a council meeting.
How measured · our arithmetic
| Input | Value | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Water a service saved, per home per year | 2 to 4 kL | Report page 21, Exhibit A |
| Tamworth residential charge, first 400 kL a year, 2026-27 | $2.01 per kL | Revenue Policy, page 20 |
| Tariff the study assumed | $3.00 per kL | Study page 14 |
| Rebates approved since 2019, and their total cost | 2,972; $261,830 | Report page 21, Exhibit B |
The arithmetic. 2 to 4 kL at $2.01 is $4.02 to $8.04 a year; at $3.00 it is $6 to $12. $261,830 divided by 2,972 is $88.10 a rebate. $88.10 divided by 4 kL is $22.03 a kilolitre, and divided by 2 kL is $44.05, so roughly $22 to $44 a kilolitre, which is about 11 to 22 times $2.01. The study's average home used about 870 litres a day, or about 318 kL a year, inside the 400 kL first tier.
Sources
Method. Researched and drafted with AI, straight from the primary sources below. Software matched 8 quotations exactly against our stored copies of their sources. How The Current works.
- Tamworth Regional Council, Business Paper, Ordinary Council, 10 November 2026 (PDF, read 11 November 2026), item 7.4, NSW Government Evaporative Air Cooler Water Use Study, pages 19 to 21: the recommendation, the study findings as summarised, the rebate scheme's cost and the proposed review. Shown in Exhibits A and B.
- NSW Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water, Understanding residential evaporative cooling water use and savings, October 2026 (PUB26/673), research by the UTS Institute for Sustainable Futures, annexure 1 to item 7.4 in Annexures, 10 November 2026 (PDF, annexure pages 165 to 182, read 11 November 2026): method, sample, flow and daily use, rebound, overnight use, faulty units, the assumed tariff and costs.
- Tamworth Regional Council, Water Rebates (web page, read 11 November 2026): the cooler servicing and ceiling fan rebates and their terms.
- Tamworth Regional Council, 2026/27 Statement of Revenue Policy (PDF, read 11 November 2026), page 20: residential water consumption tariffs, used in our arithmetic, panel C.
- Tamworth Regional Council, Minutes, Ordinary Council Meeting, 10 November 2026 (PDF, read 16 November 2026), item 7.4, minute 324/26.
- Tamworth Regional Council, Council Meeting Update (news item, read 11 November 2026), and the business papers and minutes page (read 11 November 2026, no minutes for 10 November listed).
How we did this
We read item 7.4 in the 10 November business paper in full, and the whole 18-page study annexed to it. The annexure is scanned, with no text layer, so we read it from page images and quote it from our transcription; quotations from the council's report are from its text layer, shown in the exhibits. Where the report and the study differ, on the dollar value of the saving, we have given both and explained why, using the council's published tariff. The cost per kilolitre saved is our estimate: it applies the study's average saving to the average rebate, and the study did not measure rebated services. We read the rebates page and the 2026-27 Statement of Revenue Policy for the scheme's terms and the tariff. The minutes of the 10 November meeting were not published when we wrote this, so we report the recommendation, not a decision. We did not contact the council or the department. No resident is named. The “our view” section is opinion based on the documents described.