Updated 9 November 2026. The Planning Portal page now shows the project at the response to submissions stage and has published the submissions: six in all, two in support (one from the Nunawanna Aboriginal Corporation) and four objecting, each with the name withheld. That is well short of the 50 public objections that, as the section below explains, would generally make the Independent Planning Commission the consent authority. The page also now lists a response to submissions document and 27 items of agency advice. We have not read those yet, so we cannot say whether the council has objected. We have updated what to watch.
Correction 3 November 2026. We said the state guideline and the council’s framework pulled in different directions and that, measured at the connection point, no agreement could satisfy both. That was wrong, and the answer was in the same environmental impact statement. Its consultation table records that FRV told the council on 28 November 2025 that the revised project let the contribution meet either the council’s $850 a megawatt or the guideline’s $150 a megawatt hour, and that after a meeting on 24 February 2026 the council confirmed by email that its ordinary meeting of 18 February had accepted the guideline rate. We have rewritten the section on the fund, the standfirst and our view.
Updated 31 October 2026. The exhibition has closed. When we re-read the Planning Portal page just after midnight on 31 October, it still showed the project at the exhibition stage, with exhibition dates of 2 to 30 October 2026, and it had not yet published any submissions, so we cannot yet say how many objections it received. The next stages it lists are collating submissions and the response to submissions. We changed the closing paragraph and the “how to comment” heading to the past tense.
FRV Services Australia's proposed battery at Metz, near Armidale, sits in the New England Renewable Energy Zone, and its environmental impact statement went on public exhibition on 2 October. Most of the 388 pages are what you would expect: the hazard study, noise, traffic, threatened species. The gap is in the money. The EIS commits to a community fund, sets out the rate it will use, and never states the amount.
What is proposed
FRV Services Australia wants to build a battery at Bayley Park Road, Metz, reached from
Waterfall Way, on an 8 hectare lot to be cut from a 244 hectare farming property. The
Planning Portal describes the project as The construction, operation and decommissioning
of a battery energy storage system with a capacity of up to 377 MW / 2,310 MWh, and ancillary
infrastructure.
It would connect by overhead line to the existing Transgrid 330 kV line
that runs to the Armidale substation, right beside the site.
The environmental impact statement (EIS) puts the estimated development cost at about $471
million and the battery at roughly 328 containers of lithium iron phosphate cells. Construction
would start in 2028 and run about 30 months, with up to 150 jobs at its peak and up to 5 once it
runs, mostly remotely. Its life is up to 40 years, with repowering required at 20. In
February 2026 the project won a long-duration storage agreement under Round 6 of the NSW
Electricity Infrastructure Roadmap, which the EIS describes as a mechanism that
provides revenue certainty for battery and other renewable energy projects
.
The community fund, and the figure the EIS does not give
The part of this proposal most likely to matter to Armidale over 40 years is the money it
sets aside for the community, and the EIS does not say how much that is. It says FRV
has agreed in principle that the voluntary planning agreement (VPA) will apply the maximum
contribution rate specified in the guideline
, with the final funding value to be
determined through the VPA process
.
Two documents set the terms.
- The state guideline sets a ceiling. The Department's Benefit Sharing
Guideline sets
$150 per megawatt hour per annum for stand-alone battery energy storage systems located in a rural zone
,based on installed capacity and paid over the life of the development and indexed to the Consumer Price Index
, and says the totalshould not exceed the rates outlined above
. - The council sets a floor. Armidale Regional Council's Renewable Energy
Community Benefit Framework, as it put the amended version on exhibition in February 2024,
lists a
minimum community benefit threshold
and, for batteries,$850 per megawatt of capacity for energy storage developments (including pumped hydro)
. It adds that projects falling below the thresholdare likely to be considered not in the public interest
.
Applied to this battery, our arithmetic gives three numbers, all before CPI indexation. On the 2,310 MWh the EIS gives as maximum storage capacity, the state ceiling is $346,500 a year. On the 1,840 MWh it gives at the point of connection, the ceiling is $276,000 a year. The council's rate, on 377 MW, is $320,450.
On the developer's account, the two have been reconciled. The EIS's consultation table
records that at an online meeting on 28 November 2025 FRV told the council the revised
configuration let the contribution align with both, either the ARC internal policy ($850/MW) OR the
NSW Benefit Sharing Guideline ($150/MWh)
, and that after a meeting on 24 February 2026 the
council confirmed by email that its ordinary meeting of 18 February accepted the contribution rate proposed
under the NSW Government Benefit Sharing Guideline for the Project
. Elsewhere the EIS
describes contributions calculated at an agreed rate of $150/MWh over the lifetime of the Project
.
The guideline bases its rate on installed capacity, which points to the larger 2,310 MWh figure
and about $346,500 a year. The council's battery line also does not say "per annum", as its solar and wind
lines do, so it is not clear on the page whether $850 a megawatt is meant yearly or once.
Our view: an agreed rate is good news for Armidale, but the exhibited EIS still left readers to do the sum. A community being asked to comment on a 40-year project should be told the dollar figure, which capacity number it is calculated on, and how long it is paid. At the top of the range, $346,500 a year over 40 years is about $13.9 million before indexation. That is the size of the decision being left to a later negotiation.
What the EIS says about fire, noise and the view
The hazard assessment identified 13 medium-risk and four low-risk events, most of them fires,
including battery thermal runaway, and concluded that there is negligible potential for
offsite fatality or injury
. Before battery construction starts, FRV would have to prepare a
Fire Safety Study to the satisfaction of Fire and Rescue NSW and the Planning Secretary,
including reasonable worst-case bush fire scenario
testing.
On noise, the EIS says No noise exceedances (including sleep disturbance criteria) are
relevant to construction or operation for non-associated receivers.
The one exceedance it
found is at the host property: the community-feedback table says the only exceedance
identified was related with the associated landholder
. A noise wall is listed as optional.
On the view, it reports nil or very low visual impacts
from nearby homes and public
viewpoints.
The project is also a controlled action under the Commonwealth's environment law because of listed threatened species and communities, so it is assessed under both NSW and federal rules.
What people told the developer
The EIS records what came up in its information sessions, survey and interviews. People
generally saw the location, beside the existing power line and out of public view, as
suitable. The concerns were fire (from the battery itself and from bushfire running into the
site), waste, local jobs, and housing. On housing the EIS is specific: the council
indicated a preference for construction workers to be housed outside of Armidale
so
that visitor accommodation is not lost, and the EIS leaves the accommodation strategy to the
post-approval stage.
Why the count of submissions matters
The EIS was on exhibition from 2 to 30 October 2026, and submissions were made online through
the NSW Planning Portal. The count of objections can change who decides. For state
significant development, the Department says the Independent Planning Commission is
generally the consent authority, instead of the Minister, where the council objects, where
50 or more public objections are received during exhibition
, or where the applicant has
made a reportable political donation. Petitions and identically worded submissions
are counted as a single objection
.
What to watch
Submissions closed on 30 October 2026, and the Portal lists six, four of them objections. The project is at the response to submissions stage, and the voluntary planning agreement that sets the fund's real value is still to be negotiated with the council. When it is, the figure, the capacity number it is calculated on, and how long it is paid are the three things to look for.
Sources
Method. Researched and drafted with AI, straight from the primary sources below. Software matched 3 quotations exactly against our stored copies of their sources. How The Current works.
- NSW Planning Portal, Armidale East Battery Energy Storage System, SSD-65058714 (project page, read 2 October 2026 and again just after midnight on 31 October 2026, when it still showed the exhibition stage and no published submissions, and on 9 November 2026, when it showed the response to submissions stage and six published submissions): the project description, the exhibition dates of 2 to 30 October 2026, and that submissions are made online through the Portal.
- NGH for FRV Services Australia, Environmental Impact Statement, Armidale East Battery Energy Storage System (PDF, 388 pages, Final V2.0, read 2 October 2026): site, lot sizes and connection; capacity, container count, cost, construction timing, jobs, life and repowering; the long-duration storage agreement; the agreement in principle on the community fund and the quoted council and state rates; in its consultation table, the 28 November 2025 and 24 February 2026 meetings and the council’s acceptance of the guideline rate (re-read 3 November 2026); the hazard, noise and visual findings; the Fire Safety Study requirement; the controlled-action determination; and the community issues table.
- NSW Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure, Benefit Sharing Guideline (PDF, November 2024, read 2 October 2026), page 24: the $150 per megawatt hour per annum rate for rural stand-alone batteries, the basis on installed capacity, life of the development and CPI, and that totals should not exceed the rates.
- Armidale Regional Council, Renewable Energy Community Benefit Framework (exhibition page, published 3 April 2024, read 2 October 2026): the minimum threshold, the $850 per megawatt storage line, the 2023-dollar and CPI note, and the public-interest statement.
- NSW Department of Planning, State significant development (read 2 October 2026): when the Independent Planning Commission is the consent authority, and how petitions and identical submissions are counted.
How we did this
The project figures are copied from the EIS and the Planning Portal. The three fund figures are our own arithmetic: $150 multiplied by 2,310 MWh and by 1,840 MWh, the two storage figures the EIS gives, and $850 multiplied by 377 MW. None is indexed for CPI, and none is a figure FRV, the council or the Department has published for this project. The council framework we quote is the amended version it placed on exhibition in February 2024, which the EIS also quotes; we have not confirmed whether a later version was adopted. The council’s 18 February 2026 decision is as the EIS reports it; we have not read the council’s minutes for that meeting. We did not contact FRV or the council for this piece. The “our view” paragraph is opinion based on the documents quoted.