Updated 3 November 2026. Our opening said the existing farm “is set to be replaced”. The proposal is not yet approved, so it now says “would be replaced”.

If you live around Colly Blue, about 80 kilometres west of Tamworth, the breeder farm at 4860 Coonabarabran Road would be replaced by one with about ten times as many birds. Baiada Poultry Pty Limited has lodged development application 10.2026.43.1 for a free-range broiler farm: meat chickens, grown for seven to nine weeks a batch, about six batches a year. Liverpool Plains Shire Council put it on public exhibition from Wednesday 21 October, and submissions closed on Tuesday 17 November.

It is designated development, the category that needs a full environmental impact statement, and it also needs an environment protection licence from the NSW Environment Protection Authority. One consequence matters for anyone who made a submission: under the notice, a person who objected in a submission and is dissatisfied with a decision to approve it may appeal to the Land and Environment Court.

What is proposed

The statement describes two production units of eight sheds each, every shed 176 metres long and 18.5 metres wide, with fenced free-range areas between them that birds can use from about 21 days old. Each shed holds up to 61,000 birds. The site carries 24 feed silos, two 23,000 litre LPG tanks for heating, two backup diesel generators, and a cold-storage container for dead birds. The existing breeder farm on the site, 12 sheds and up to 90,000 birds, would stop operating.

The estimated development cost is $29,031,313. The statement expects a construction period of 9 to 12 months, about 50 construction jobs, and seven full-time equivalent jobs once running. It estimates water use at about 82 megalitres a year, drawn from the two existing bores on the property, which it says now run on basic landholder rights; a water access licence will be purchased, subject to approval.

The traffic study puts operating traffic at about 15 to 16 heavy vehicle trips and 12 light vehicle trips a day, entering from Coonabarabran Road, an approved B-double route. Most heavy vehicles run in daylight, but birds can be collected at night, and the study allows for up to 38 heavy vehicle trips on a peak collection night.

Why Colly Blue: the Tamworth plant

The statement is plain about what the farm is for. It says Baiada has begun operating its Oakburn processing plant in Tamworth, a state significant development, which will lift poultry processing in the region from 840,000 to 3 million birds a week, and that supplying it needs about 350 additional sheds within a two-hour drive. It says Baiada is Australia's largest poultry meat producer, supplying about 35 per cent of national demand. Colly Blue is 16 of those 350 sheds. If the statement's figure holds, applications like this one will keep arriving across our patch for years.

The nearest home, and the odour test

Odour is the risk the consultants themselves rank highest. Their assessment, by Benbow Environmental, models ten homes. Nine come in under the adopted criterion of 6 odour units, the closest call being a home about 1,450 metres south-west at 5.36. The tenth, labelled R2 and placed about 600 metres east, is predicted at 12.9. In the results table its criterion and compliance columns read N/A.

The reason is in the text: A commercial agreement will be obtained from the nearest impacted receptor R2. The statement, dated 13 October, describes the same arrangement in the present tense: Baiada is currently negotiating a neighbour agreement, and Subject to finalisation of this agreement, this dwelling will not be considered a sensitive receptor for the purpose of the odour or noise impact assessments. Neither document says the agreement has been signed.

The same home is missing from the noise study. Its consultants list it as a private dwelling about 700 metres from the nearest shed and say it is not considered to be a sensitive receiver for the purposes of this assessment, so their compliance table, which reads Yes on every row, starts at homes more than a kilometre from the nearest shed. The figures for the nearest home appear not in the noise study but in the statement's reply to that neighbour's consultation response, which says operational noise there is predicted to exceed the evening criterion by up to 5 decibels, and the night criterion by up to 1 decibel in typical conditions and up to 5 during temperature inversions. The statement says the agreement would include improvements to the home's windows, doors and air conditioners, so it can be closed up.

Two more details sit behind the odour numbers. Every prediction already includes a 40 per cent reduction the consultants adopted for the screening effect of surrounding vegetation, which they call conservative and support from published studies. And the criterion itself depends on how many people live nearby: the state method sets a looser limit where fewer people are inside the modelled 2 odour unit line. Three homes are inside it here, which is how the assessment arrives at 6.

Where the statement and its own study disagree

The statement's executive summary says the odour assessment covered cumulative impacts from surrounding broiler farms. The odour assessment says the opposite. Its section on cumulative impacts says the state's approved methods do not require a cumulative assessment, that there is no significant odour source of a similar development in the immediate surrounding area, and that No further assessment is considered warranted. On this site that may be fair today. It is the summary that a busy reader, or a councillor, is most likely to rely on, and it describes work the study did not do.

Now that submissions have closed

The exhibition ran to Tuesday 17 November, and the council's public notice page (source 1) now reads No longer on display. The notice said submissions are NOT kept confidential. The council assesses the application next, with the EPA's general terms of approval for the licence; we have not yet seen an assessment report.

Our view

Much of this application is careful work. It carries separate studies on traffic, stormwater, bushfire and hazards, the farm sits well back from the road behind mature timber, and replacing an old breeder farm on land already used for poultry is a reasonable place to put sheds the region's processing plant is going to need. But the headline finding that the farm complies on odour and noise is true only because the one home it does not comply at has been taken out of the test, on the strength of an agreement the documents describe as still being negotiated. If the council approves it, the least it should ask is that the agreement be signed before any birds arrive, with an enforceable fallback if it is not; the odour study already lists an Odour Enclosure system as a contingency measure. And with hundreds more sheds to come, the council should correct the record on cumulative odour now, because the next application will cite this one.

What to watch

The EPA's general terms of approval for the licence; the council's assessment report and whether its conditions deal with the nearest home; and further broiler farm applications across the region as Oakburn's supply grows.

Sources

Method. Researched and drafted with AI, straight from the primary sources below. How The Current works.

  1. Liverpool Plains Shire Council, Development Proposal DA 10.2026.43.1 (PAN 683185) (public notice, read 28 October 2026): the applicant, consent authority, site, development type, the exhibition period (21 October to 17 November 2026), the EPA licence, how to make a submission, the disclosure and confidentiality terms, and the objector's right of appeal.
  2. PSA Consulting for Baiada Poultry, Colly Blue Free Range Broiler Farm, Environmental Impact Statement (version 3, 13 October 2026, read 28 October 2026): the summary of findings, including the cumulative odour statement, the cost and jobs (pages iv to ix); Baiada's share of national supply (page 1); the site's location (page 10); the existing breeder farm, shed sizes and bird numbers (page 1); Oakburn and the 350 sheds (pages 3 to 5); water supply (pages 25 and 26); construction period (page 26); consultation and the neighbour agreement (pages 37 to 38); and the reply to the nearest neighbour, including the predicted noise exceedances and the improvements to the home (pages 39 and 40).
  3. Benbow Environmental, Air Quality Impact Assessment (appendix 11, October 2026, read 28 October 2026): the executive summary (page i); how the 6 odour unit criterion was set (page 16); the 40 per cent vegetation reduction (page 36); Table 5-8, the odour predictions at each home (page 37); cumulative impacts (page 39); the contingency odour enclosure (page 60); and the statement of impact (page 61).
  4. SoundIN, Noise and Vibration Impact Assessment (appendix 12, report 17361, read 28 October 2026): the receivers and the excluded dwelling (pages 4 to 6) and Table 4-9, the predicted operational noise (page 26).
  5. PSA Consulting, Traffic Impact Assessment (appendix 10, 12 October 2026, read 28 October 2026): operational traffic and night collection, section 3.2.2 (PDF page 13).

How we did this

We found the notice on the council's public notices page and downloaded the statement and the odour, noise, traffic and shed plan appendices on 28 October 2026, then read them as text. The council publishes a further seven appendices we have not read in full. The reports place the nearest home at slightly different distances (about 600 metres in the odour study, about 690 in the statement, about 700 to the nearest shed in the noise study); we give each figure as its source does. We do not identify the nearest home or its occupants, and we have left out the personal details in their consultation response. Baiada's figures for Oakburn, the 350 sheds and its national market share are the company's own, as stated in its application; we have not checked them against another source. We did not contact Baiada or the council for this piece. The “our view” section is opinion based on the documents described.